Underrun heels are a very common problem (or pathology) with hooves. It’s so common to see underrun heels that many people don’t even realise that it’s not ‘normal’ for a hoof to be that shape.
You’ll often hear them called low heels, though I’d argue that you can have low heels without them being underrun, it looks pretty similar. You’ll also hear the terms, underslung heels, collapsed heels or, if people are getting really technical ‘splaty foot’ (used a lot with TB’s – they have an upright foot and a splaty foot; right?)
Lets define our terms. What are underrun heels?
Sometimes they are defined as when the tubules of the heels are at a more shallow angle than at the toe. But I don’t like that… I’ll show you why…
Here’s a diagram of underrun heels using the above definition
Yep, that works fine. Only… here’s a diagram of the exact same heel angle but they wouldn’t be defined as underrun by the above definition.
Why? Because the toe has ‘run forward’ too, as it very frequently does when you have underrun heels. I would love love LOVE it if the toe running forward cancelled out the heels being underrun. But alas it doesn’t, it just means you’ve got underrun heels AND a toe too far out the front.
I prefer to use the definition of the heels are further forward than the widest part of the frog.
Widest part of the frog is the green line. Back of the heels is the orange line.
With the heels running forwards like this, the quarters can get pushed out to the side. This can be mistaken for flare, particularly if someone is using a photo to assess the hoof.
I have no explanation for the pink tint on this photo, so please don’t let it distract you from seeing that flare! Granted, there’s not a huge amount of flare on this foot, it can get a lot worse where underrun heels are involved. This is how flare is commonly assessed, particularly if giving an opinion from a photo. But is it flare…
This is a side shot from where I was holding the rasp to show the flare. The rasp is being held in the direction the tubules should be going if the heels weren’t underrun. You often don’t get to see it from this side and compare when you’re looking a photo.
Here’s how it looks when I’m holding the rasp in the direction of the tubules, which is how you should be assessing the flare
You can see how the rasp is at the same angle as the tubules of the hoof wall.
TA DA! Flare be gone! No trimming needed!
It really does depend how you look at things!
In the next part, I’m going to show you what’s going on inside the hoof with underrun heels.
How does it affect the laminae?
What happens to the pedal bone.
What’s going on with the lateral cartilage.
All the stuff you don’t see when the hoof capsule is in the way.
Underrun Heels Explained Part 2 is here
NB. Not for the squemish!
Underrun Heels Explained Part 3 is here
Does your horse have underrun heels? Are you not so sure now you’ve read this post?
Got any questions, comments or concerns…
Let me know in the comments box below, or over on the facebook page.
GET THIS GUIDE and more with a FREE Hoof Geek Academy membership
How To Take A Digital Pulse
Never miss a blog post, and get priority notifications of new courses and offers.
OMG! Best article I have ever seen in this! Thank you so much. A lightbulb just went off for me. My mare has bad underrun heels due to always keeping the heels a little long due to the central sulcus thrush that I am always fighting. I was told that if I take off too much heel, she will be lame and not move enough to stimulate her frog! I believe this to be somewhat true but now I think we are in a vicious cycle. Not sure which one takes priority.
I do like a good lightbulb moment 🙂
At the risk of making this a frustrating answer… it depends.
Underrun heels often need to be ‘longer’ to prevent the pedal bone being ground parallel. I can’t tell from your description if they really are long. If you have a weak frog, then the heels being longer than the frog may because the frog is short, not because the heels are long.
In that case trimming the heels to match the frog would be taking a good(ish) structure and making it match a bad one. There’s a lot of problems that can cause.
The fact you’ve got those problems makes me suspicious that diet isn’t right, or inflammation is a problem (or both). There’s also the possibilty of shoulder issues (if we’re talking front feet – tall heels behind can be much more complicated, either way get a good bodyworker to look at your horse)
Good therapeutic pads can get round the issue by shaping to the underside of the hoof, so you get contact on the frog without over lowering the heels. These are the ones I use http://www.equinepodiatrysupplies.co.uk/product/pair-eps-7lb-pads/
Amen and amen. My farrier in America was very adept at keeping my horse, who has a very strong tendency to get under-run heels, balanced sound and happy for over a decade. I moved him to France permanently and have been going crazy trying to find someone who actually understands horses hooves and underpin heels – they just chop the toe off and call it a day….sigh…
I have a horse with under run heels, my main concern is the fact that I haven’t found a competent trimmer with experience, at at this point I asked myself why would it be better to shoe him, is there a shoe in the process that could help ? thanks for now !
My older barrel horse seems to have those kind of heels..What can i suggest to my horse shoer to get them started on a better direction
he sometimes is lame when barefoot.
[…] In part 1 we looked at the hoof capsule, In part 2 we looked at the position of the internal structures, Now let’s look at how they go together… […]
Great info thanks Debs 🙂
Hopefully you recognise some of that! 🙂
That is a very interesting post! and just shows how different things can look by tweaking the equipment. I believe my boy has underrun heels and also flare which I have worried endlessly about and bought a rasp to tackle it but my trimmer says its really not that bad so the rasp was a bit of a waste of money as she sees no reason to do anything between trims.
well as you can see here he might not have as much flare as you think.
Trust your trimmer. It’s what’s going on on the inside that counts…
Besides – trimming flare is really hard work, Use the time and energy to have fun with the fella 🙂